LSAT and Law School Admissions Forum

Get expert LSAT preparation and law school admissions advice from PowerScore Test Preparation.

General questions relating to law school or law school admissions.
 TexasHays
  • Posts: 2
  • Joined: Jan 03, 2016
|
#21429
I saw your twitter post suggesting posting personal statements here for some basic feedback and I thought I'd take you up on it!

I hate personal statements. I don't feel like I've overcome any major obstacles or have any captivating personal stories, so I tried to talk about my passion instead. I don't really like the statement very much but not sure where to take it.
I've removed any personal identifiable information and would greatly appreciate any helpful criticism.

Thanks!

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

What is “just”? It was not until the last few months of my final year at University that I began to struggle with that question. Despite competing in debate throughout high school and college, I knew only enough to win a debate. I had my own personal ideas and beliefs and that was sufficient at the time. But as a Religious Studies student, my last semester primarily focused on the religious and political atmosphere of the 1960s. This curriculum introduced me to Dr. James Cone and “liberation theology.” The idea that “God”, or more simply put, “Justice”, was, and should always be, on the side of the oppressed is a powerful one. Even more than that, however, was the idea that no overarching idea of justice could truly be universal. That every decision made and idea formulated would tie into specific historical and cultural contexts was a revelation to me. This idea of context and nuance has stuck with me my entire adult life. That, coupled with the push for open discourse and dialogue promoted by Dr. Sandel in “Justice” has forever changed me. A passion was ignited in me that I never felt before and I fell in love with learning and reading again, something that alluded me for most of my college experience.
I have seen my mother battle my entire life against employers and insurance companies on account of her Multiple Sclerosis. I have seen my father almost lose his entire savings because of a brain tumor. I have seen family and friends lose careers and opportunities because of their race, ethnicity, and other intangible facets of their identities. Though I have been fortunate, I have seen firsthand what happens when society and the legal system is abused by those seeking power or profits. I fervently believe, however, that the legal system is the best defense against those injustices.
I have my own biases and beliefs in politics.Despite that, when I indulge in political discussions with friends or strangers I try not to promote my particular beliefs. Instead, I ask questions and push for context and nuance because I fervently belief that generalizations and sweeping decrees about a topic are unhealthy at best and dangerous at worst. I have been wanting to take this passion of mine and forge a career out of it for years, but instead I found a thriving career at <redacted> and made due with volunteering on my personal time. I chose to not pursue graduate or law school out of fear: fear of debt and of failure.
I now stand at a crossroads. I could remain at my current job and live a quite comfortable life, or I can follow my dream of pursuing the study of law. For me, the law is not merely a set of documents by which we live and work. It is a direct reflection of the values we hold most dear. That everyone has the right to speak their mind regardless of the popularity of their message. That everyone is afforded due process. That the will of the majority can never come before the rights of the minority. I no longer am willing to remain a spectator. I wish to become a participant in the discussion and debate over what is “just”.
User avatar
 Dave Killoran
PowerScore Staff
  • PowerScore Staff
  • Posts: 5994
  • Joined: Mar 25, 2011
|
#21436
TexasHays wrote:I saw your twitter post suggesting posting personal statements here for some basic feedback and I thought I'd take you up on it!

I hate personal statements. I don't feel like I've overcome any major obstacles or have any captivating personal stories, so I tried to talk about my passion instead. I don't really like the statement very much but not sure where to take it.
I've removed any personal identifiable information and would greatly appreciate any helpful criticism.

Thanks!

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

What is “just”? It was not until the last few months of my final year at University that I began to struggle with that question. Despite competing in debate throughout high school and college, I knew only enough to win a debate. I had my own personal ideas and beliefs and that was sufficient at the time. But as a Religious Studies student, my last semester primarily focused on the religious and political atmosphere of the 1960s. This curriculum introduced me to Dr. James Cone and “liberation theology.” The idea that “God”, or more simply put, “Justice”, was, and should always be, on the side of the oppressed is a powerful one. Even more than that, however, was the idea that no overarching idea of justice could truly be universal. That every decision made and idea formulated would tie into specific historical and cultural contexts was a revelation to me. This idea of context and nuance has stuck with me my entire adult life. That, coupled with the push for open discourse and dialogue promoted by Dr. Sandel in “Justice” has forever changed me. A passion was ignited in me that I never felt before and I fell in love with learning and reading again, something that alluded me for most of my college experience.
I have seen my mother battle my entire life against employers and insurance companies on account of her Multiple Sclerosis. I have seen my father almost lose his entire savings because of a brain tumor. I have seen family and friends lose careers and opportunities because of their race, ethnicity, and other intangible facets of their identities. Though I have been fortunate, I have seen firsthand what happens when society and the legal system is abused by those seeking power or profits. I fervently believe, however, that the legal system is the best defense against those injustices.
I have my own biases and beliefs in politics.Despite that, when I indulge in political discussions with friends or strangers I try not to promote my particular beliefs. Instead, I ask questions and push for context and nuance because I fervently belief that generalizations and sweeping decrees about a topic are unhealthy at best and dangerous at worst. I have been wanting to take this passion of mine and forge a career out of it for years, but instead I found a thriving career at <redacted> and made due with volunteering on my personal time. I chose to not pursue graduate or law school out of fear: fear of debt and of failure.
I now stand at a crossroads. I could remain at my current job and live a quite comfortable life, or I can follow my dream of pursuing the study of law. For me, the law is not merely a set of documents by which we live and work. It is a direct reflection of the values we hold most dear. That everyone has the right to speak their mind regardless of the popularity of their message. That everyone is afforded due process. That the will of the majority can never come before the rights of the minority. I no longer am willing to remain a spectator. I wish to become a participant in the discussion and debate over what is “just”.
Hi Texas,

Thanks for posting this! I can see where you are struggling with this, but I will say that you also have some really good pieces to work with, a good presentation style, and that there is potential here to ultimately produce a really good essay. As with all comments I make, my goal is to help make your essay better so forgive me for being critical at times :-D

In your opening, you've gone along a route that is used by more than a few applicants, namely posing a question of some legal relevance. I do like how you go into a discussion of ideas thereafter, but I also think this essay is missing it's most essential component, which is us learning more about you. I know this it is terribly difficult to write about yourself in this context, but that's the task they've given you. For example, you mention that, "This idea of context and nuance has stuck with me my entire adult life," but that doesn't tell me a whole lot about who you really are. And that's what I want more of in this essay. Later, you mention that a passion was ignited inside of you, but you don't take it anywhere beyond mentioning that you enjoyed learning again. So, it loses impact and seems like more of a convenient claim. How to rectify that? show me what the passion lead to, explain to me how it changed your life. That's how you want to think about every single thing you say in this essay.

Now, as you move into the second paragraph, this essay really changes and you reference situations that I really want to hear more about. But, here's where I feel you struggling to determine what they want. You can' mention serious situations like that and not give me at least a bit more info (How did they affect you? How did you feel? What happened?). They have so much nuance that they leave me wanting more.

In the third paragraph, you go into some classic "telling" me moments (" I ask questions and push for context...") when what you want to do is show me, not tell me. The example I often us is: don't tell me you are a hero; show me instead that you are a hero by talking about the time you rescued someone form a burning house.

In the last paragraph you want to be careful about telling them what the law is. A lot of people do it, and the problem is that again, it doesn't tell them anything about you, and instead tells them something about a topic they are really familiar with (and probably know better than most people).

I'd say you want to narrow your theme a bit, and put the focus on how all these ideas relate to you and your life. They need to get a definite sense of who you are through this story. I think the potential is there!

Please let me know if that helps. Thanks!
 TexasHays
  • Posts: 2
  • Joined: Jan 03, 2016
|
#21439
Thanks a ton! I won't take up more of your time by asking you to reread it but your assessment totally nailed it down.

I included some details in the first paragraph as to what that passion has led me to do, I expanded on some stories in the second paragraph (I didn't want to make it seem I was capitalizing on my parents' misfortune), tried to "show" more in the third paragraph, and removed the last few lines of the last paragraph explaining the law. That was great advice. Instead I focused on what I wanted to do instead.

You're a life saver! Now I just can't wait for grey day!
User avatar
 Dave Killoran
PowerScore Staff
  • PowerScore Staff
  • Posts: 5994
  • Joined: Mar 25, 2011
|
#21440
Hi Texas,

Glad that helps! Now, go through it again, word-by-word. Look to make sure that every singlet hing you say has value and gives the impression you want. Go through it very carefully and slowly. Almost all writing can be made smoother, and fast changes often introduce different issues. So, just make sure you have all bases covered :-D

Me too—I'm thinking tomorrow for scores but we'll see!

Thanks!

Get the most out of your LSAT Prep Plus subscription.

Analyze and track your performance with our Testing and Analytics Package.