Premise and Conclusion Analysis Drill - Difference in Analysis

[sstroud]

Hey Dave,
At the end of chapter 2 I broke down each of the questions and evaluated each argument. While the book and I had nearly identical breakdowns of each question, on questions 1 and 3 I had a different opinion of the strength of argument compared to the book, is this a major issue and if it is how can I correct it?

[Dave Killoran]

Hi S,

Thanks for the question! No, this isn't a major issue. When you are learning, you expect to miss some things Instead of that being bad, it's actually very helpful!

What you should do now is go back to those two where there was a difference and see why that difference existed. what did I see that you didn't, and how different are the analyses from what you thought?

Honestly, having identical breakdowns on all the others is quite good, and so I'd say look at this as the glass is half full, not half empty

Thanks!