LSAT and Law School Admissions Forum

Get expert LSAT preparation and law school admissions advice from PowerScore Test Preparation.

General questions relating to law school or law school admissions.
 zanardin
  • Posts: 7
  • Joined: Nov 09, 2013
|
#12382
Hello, I want to share what I hope is my final ps draft, if anyone has time to offer any comments edits or suggestions I would really appreciate it!

My two main concerns: 1. I only talk about one experience, should I try to discuss more? 2. I need to cut 150 words for one of the schools I am applying to, and I am finding it very difficult.


I did not realize I was different until I was 22. Literally overnight, I went from being normal to a strange intruder. Suddenly, I was acutely aware of the color of my skin and how I spoke. Everything I did, from waiting for the bus to running at the local YMCA, caused people to stare and call me names. I was a white, privileged young woman living in Central Harlem, and for the first time I was uncomfortable with myself.

My experience as a member of the Jesuit Volunteer Corps challenged me to open up to the reality outside of my bubble. Learning to live and work in neighborhoods of New York City that most people avoid helped me better understand myself and those around me, successfully interact with people from diverse backgrounds, and develop a concrete sense of how I can best serve others. My experience as a Jesuit Volunteer made me realize how I can translate my commitment to others into the practice of law in order to contribute to the development of a more just and sustainable society.

When I decided to follow my passion for helping others through a post-graduate service program, I had little idea of how hard it was going to be, or how much it would affect me. In high school and college, I did service work on my own terms. I only rarely and briefly ventured outside of my comfort zone, and just scratched the surface of the communities I reached out to. As a Jesuit Volunteer, that all changed. I lived with seven other volunteers in an old convent in an almost exclusively African American community. I worked throughout the Bronx, Brooklyn, and Queens in rent-stabilized apartment buildings where landlords neglected conditions and exploited tenants. And I was the different one; immersed way over my head in an alien environment plagued by injustices that I had no idea how to solve. Not knowing what else to do, I moved forward as if I were still inside my bubble. I did research, made brochures, and went out to tell tenants why and how they should organize a tenant association. But my words were aimless. I had created invisible boundaries around the tenants that I thought I could not cross. My apprehension prevented me from really knowing their lives and responding to their ideas. But the tenants at 2425 Nostrand Avenue in Flatbush Brooklyn, a building primarily occupied by Trinidadian immigrants, challenged me to overcome my fear and preconceptions.

The first meeting I held on Nostrand Avenue was the second tenant meeting I ever led. “Look!” a thin older man shouted after I had delivered my introduction. “I was the president of the old tenant association, we’ve already tried it. Why should we even listen to you?” I was sure that every person in the crowded lobby could feel the sensation of sweat accumulating on the inside of my shirt. “Okay,” I stammered. “It sounds like you all aren’t interested in organizing another tenant association.” After mumbling something about my contact information, I rushed out of the building. I had never been so blatantly called out by anyone who I had tried to help; I felt so lost. I wanted to forget about the tenants on Nostrand Avenue. Then Marie called. She said she was done putting up with broken stoves and illegal eviction notices. She asked me to come back. This time instead of asking tenants to listen to me, I decided to listen to her. A week later at Marie’s kitchen table, she told me they wanted to file a Housing Part petition against their landlord for failure to meet conditions requirements, and they needed assistance. I did not know anything about housing court, but her desperate eyes pulled me in.

Working with the tenants of 2425 Nostrand Avenue was physically and emotionally exhausting. I traveled almost two hours to the building countless times. I spent evenings knocking on apartment doors to collect intake forms and evidence and talked with tenant leaders for hours. I sat with a crying mother in her mold-infested apartment, stood with tenants in the stuck elevator multiple times, and listened to intimidating voicemails from the landlord on tenants’ phones. I experienced suffering and injustice in the most raw and personal way. At the same time, I learned to listen, teach, and collaborate with the people I served. As I grew more invested in the lives of the tenants, I overcame my fear of being different. I broke down the barriers I had constructed and built effective relationships with those around me. I embraced unfamiliarity and invested the time to appreciate peoples’ obstacles, ideas, and potential separate from my own opinions and ego. I helped people succeed on their own terms, and it was the most powerful and fulfilling work I had ever done.

My work as a Jesuit Volunteer pulled me away from the narrow lens through which I viewed the world and I gained a new perspective from within the communities I came to love. The experience was defining because it helped me make sense of my passion for helping others through understanding how I can intertwine direct service with broader system change. I realized my role as an advocate who walks beside the marginalized to help them build change one step at a time. As a tenant organizer, I was able to help tenants build community awareness and long-term campaigns. But I was frustrated with my inability to help them achieve specific results and tangible control. Through my work in housing court to help tenants from Nostrand Avenue win a class action and get the repairs they deserved, I learned how the law can be a powerful tool for those who are otherwise disadvantaged. I am dedicated to studying law because it will allow me to pursue a career in which I use my education, experience, and skills to be an agent of positive change in individual lives and communities.
 Ron Gore
PowerScore Staff
  • PowerScore Staff
  • Posts: 220
  • Joined: May 15, 2013
|
#12390
Hi, Zanardin!

I think you've got a great draft of your personal statement. It really pulled me in, and I could visualize you knocking on doors, getting stuck in elevators, etc. Since you've asked for critiques, here are some of my thoughts. You may get other responses as well, so I encourage you to take the responses in and synthesize the recommendations before you do any more edits.

While I felt pulled in, it wasn't until the thin, older resident called you out in your first meeting at Nostrand Avenue. I would start there. His comment, and your initial response, shows much of everything you say in the first couple of paragraphs. You were an outsider ("we" vs. "you"), different, young and inexperienced (based on your quick retreat. :)

The fact that you were open to coming back shows your courage, passion, and willingness to sacrifice your comfort to help others.

Unlike the second part of the essay, the first came across as more of a generic statement that you are a privileged person who felt threatened by living in a community that is foreign because its residents are of a different race and a "lower" social or economic station. That message inherently contains some judgment of others and of yourself in relation to them that can be interpreted (even if incorrectly) in a negative way.

The value of your experience was not that you drummed up the courage to live among people who are of a different racial and economic group than you. Even though such a transition is actually very difficult and uncomfortable, in an abstract sense many people tend to take for granted that an unbiased person should be able to do that. The value of your experience is that your desire to help others led you to face your own inadequacies and to truly connect with people so that they could teach you how to help them. That is a compelling and positive narrative without much room for negative interpretation.

So, I would recommend ditching the first few paragraphs, starting with the older man yelling at you, and then weave only the necessary biographical details and facts about your program into the narrative. On that front, I think your age is your key biographical factor. It is your best hook, because it conveys vulnerability without courting the possibility of negative inferences regarding race. Also, you don't have to mention your relative socioeconomic privilege explicitly, because most readers will infer it from the context of you working to help the people at Nostrand Avenue as part of your post-graduate service program.

Cutting those first paragraphs would shorten your essay, let you begin with a dramatic hook, remove the portions that could be misinterpreted, and leave the reader feeling inspired about you and what you can bring to their school. I know that your essay inspired me.

Thanks, and best wishes -

Ron
User avatar
 Dave Killoran
PowerScore Staff
  • PowerScore Staff
  • Posts: 5994
  • Joined: Mar 25, 2011
|
#12401
Hi Zanardin,

There's a lot in this draft that is very compelling, and perhaps most importantly, I feel your sincerity. What you are writing about means something to you, and that comes across with authenticity. This is really a positive achievement, because it's extremely hard to to do for most people. So, I think you are working from a very good platform :-D

That said, as Ron noted, I think you can still improve this, and make it even more engaging. For me, the first paragraph isn't a problem, but like Ron I feel that the second paragraph and parts of the third are more about telling us how you feel than showing it (if you haven't already, check out the Personal Statement seminar I held recently, available for free at http://www.powerscore.com/lsat/help/#free-lessons. I talk about the show/tell concept). I would agree that moving the fourth paragraph up in the essay would a positive (in fact, I agree with pretty much everything Ron said here).

As far as discussing just one experience, that's not a problem at all. You sue this experience to talk about your life and changes to your viewpoint, as well as how this logically connects to law school. In that sense, this experience is robust enough to occupy the entire essay. I wouldn't worry about adding anything else.

The edits you seek would be addressed by moving up the meeting story. That would allow you to cut statements like, "When I decided to follow my passion for helping others through a post-graduate service program, I had little idea of how hard it was going to be, or how much it would affect me." That sentence, while well-written, is shown elsewhere in the essay, and also is a bit general ("passion for helping others" is, no offense intended, cliche). Carefully look at each sentence in this essay and stamp out anything that seems like it could apply to anyone applying to law school or is simply obviously true (example: "I learned how the law can be a powerful tool for those who are otherwise disadvantaged." Law being powerful is something mentioned by thousands of applicants--see the Personal Statement seminar recording linked above for why that's not a good thing to have in your essay).

Overall, I really like this. It's pretty good right now, and has the potential to be exceptional. That's not something you see or read every day, so congrats on your progress thus far.

I look forward to seeing another draft if you choose to give it a shot. Thanks!
 zanardin
  • Posts: 7
  • Joined: Nov 09, 2013
|
#12403
Thank you both for your genuine comments, I really appreciate you taking the time to loko over my ps. Below is a new draft, with your suggestions taken into account. The underlined lines are one I am hesitant about after reading your thoughts, please let me know if you think I should take them out or not. Any other comments also appreciated.



The first meeting I held at 2425 Nostrand Avenue was the second tenant meeting I ever led. “Look!” a thin, graying man shouted after I delivered my introduction. “I was the president of the old tenant association, we’ve already tried it. Why should we even listen to you?” I was sure that every person in the crowded lobby could feel the sensation of sweat accumulating on the inside of my shirt. “Okay,” I stammered. “It sounds like you all aren’t interested in organizing another tenant association.” After mumbling something about my contact information, I rushed out of the building. I had never been so blatantly called out by anyone who I had tried to help; I felt so lost.

Through learning to live and work in marginalized neighborhoods of New York City, I faced my own inadequacies to better understand myself in order to successfully interact with people from diverse backgrounds and develop a concrete sense of how I can best serve others. My experience in the post-graduate Jesuit Volunteer Corps made me realize how I can translate my commitment to others into the practice of law in order to help others improve their lives and contribute to a more just and sustainable society.

In high school and college, I did service work on my own terms. I only rarely and briefly ventured outside of my comfort zone, and just scratched the surface of the communities I reached out to. As a Jesuit Volunteer, that all changed. I lived with seven other volunteers an old convent in an almost exclusively African American community. Everything I did, from waiting for the bus to running at the local YMCA, caused people to stare and call me names. I worked throughout majority minority neighborhoods of the Bronx, Brooklyn, and Queens in rent-stabilized apartment buildings where landlords neglected conditions and exploited tenants. I felt like a strange intruder in other people’s lives, and I was acutely aware of my appearance and actions. For the first time, I was uncomfortable with myself.

I quickly became immersed way over my head in an alien environment plagued by injustices that I had no idea how to solve. Not knowing what else to do, I moved forward as if I were still inside my bubble. I did research, made brochures, and went out to tell tenants why and how they should organize a tenant association. But my words were aimless. I had created invisible boundaries around the tenants that I thought I could not cross. My apprehension prevented me from really knowing their lives and responding to their ideas. But the tenants at 2425 Nostrand Avenue in Flatbush Brooklyn, a building primarily occupied by Trinidadian immigrants, challenged me to overcome my fear and preconceptions.


After the first meeting, I wanted to forget about the tenants on Nostrand Avenue. Then Marie called. She said she was done putting up with broken stoves and illegal eviction notices. She asked me to come back. This time instead of asking tenants to listen to me, I decided to listen to her. A week later at Marie’s kitchen table, she told me they wanted to file a Housing Part petition against their landlord for failure to meet conditions requirements, and they needed assistance. I did not know anything about housing court, but her desperate eyes pulled me in.

Working with the tenants of 2425 Nostrand Avenue was physically and emotionally exhausting. I traveled almost two hours to the building countless times. I spent evenings knocking on apartment doors to collect intake forms and evidence and talked with tenant leaders for hours. I sat with a crying mother in her mold-infested apartment, stood with tenants in the broken elevator multiple times, and listened to intimidating voicemails from the landlord on tenants’ phones. I experienced suffering and injustice in the most raw and personal way. At the same time, I learned to listen, teach, and collaborate with the people I served. As I grew more invested in the lives of the tenants, I overcame my fear of being different. I broke down the barriers I had constructed and built effective relationships with those around me. I embraced unfamiliarity and invested the time to appreciate peoples’ obstacles, ideas, and potential, separate from my own opinions and ego. I helped people succeed on their own terms, and it was the most powerful and fulfilling work I had ever done.

My work as a Jesuit Volunteer pulled me away from the narrow lens through which I viewed the world and I gained a new perspective from within the communities I came to love. The experience was defining because it helped me make sense of my passion for helping others through understanding how I can intertwine direct service with broader system change. I realized my role as an advocate who walks beside the marginalized to help them build change one step at a time. As a tenant organizer, I was able to help tenants build community awareness and long-term campaigns and issue complaints with various agencies. But I was frustrated with my inability to help them achieve specific results. It was only through my work in housing court with residents of 2425 Nostrand Avenue as well as other tenant groups who had the representation of an attorney, I was able to assist people to achieve real improvements and control over the issues they faced. I am dedicated to studying law because it will allow me to pursue a career in which I use my education, experience, and skills to be an agent of positive change in individual lives and communities.
 Ron Gore
PowerScore Staff
  • PowerScore Staff
  • Posts: 220
  • Joined: May 15, 2013
|
#12412
Hi Zanardin,

This essay is getting very strong, though I still think you could do some trimming to it. Remember, this is just my opinion, and even other members of my own team may disagree.

The current placement of paragraphs 2, 3 and 4 takes me out of the narrative. I would drop those paragraphs and bring current paragraphs 5, 6 and 7 up, making them revised paragraphs 2, 3 and 4 respectively.

I also think you cover a lot of what you are saying in current paragraphs 2,3 and 4 by actually showing it as part of your story in current paragraphs 5,6 and 7, or you can easily add a phrase here and there to cover it. You may also want to break up some of the paragraphs to make them shorter. Most people get bogged down in longer paragraphs, while strategic paragraph breaks can propel them forward.

Now, I have a tendency to cut, cut, cut, and because of that my writing can sometimes come across as cold. Naturally, your style is different than mine, and mine is not necessarily better. Here is a way to think about it: for each statement you have in your essay, consider whether that same information is provided elsewhere. If it is, why do you have it twice? There may be a good reason for the repetition, or it may just be redundant.

While some people have a brevity issue, I don't think in your case that you should be afraid of writing too little, as you are still over two pages, double-spaced. Just be sure that what you write says what you intend in an efficient and effective manner.

Here's what I mean:

Current Para 2: Through learning to live and work in marginalized neighborhoods of New York City [could add expanded location reference to first sentence of para 1], I faced my own inadequacies to better understand myself in order to successfully interact with people from diverse backgrounds and develop a concrete sense of how I can best serve others.[is shown in para 6] My experience in the post-graduate Jesuit Volunteer Corps made me realize how I can translate my commitment to others into the practice of law in order to help others improve their lives and contribute to a more just and sustainable society. [other than the name of the program, is shown in paragraph 7]

In high school and college, I did service work on my own terms. [could add as a brief statement of contrast in current paragraph 6] I only rarely and briefly ventured outside of my comfort zone, and just scratched the surface of the communities I reached out to. As a Jesuit Volunteer, that all changed. [this change is shown in current paragraph 6, and the reader instinctively knows from the nature of the change what you were like before]I lived with seven other volunteers an old convent [this is not shown]in an almost exclusively African American community. Everything I did, from waiting for the bus to running at the local YMCA, caused people to stare and call me names. I worked throughout majority minority neighborhoods of the Bronx, Brooklyn, and Queens in rent-stabilized apartment buildings where landlords neglected conditions and exploited tenants. I felt like a strange intruder in other people’s lives, and I was acutely aware of my appearance and actions. [I feel like these several statements are, in essence, shown in your story - but I may be overstating this one] For the first time, I was uncomfortable with myself. [This is a great line, and could be added to the end of para 1]

[I feel like most of this paragraph is shown in current paragraphs 5, 6 and 7] I quickly became immersed way over my head in an alien environment plagued by injustices that I had no idea how to solve. Not knowing what else to do, I moved forward as if I were still inside my bubble. I did research, made brochures, and went out to tell tenants why and how they should organize a tenant association. But my words were aimless. I had created invisible boundaries around the tenants that I thought I could not cross. My apprehension prevented me from really knowing their lives and responding to their ideas. But the tenants at 2425 Nostrand Avenue in Flatbush Brooklyn, a building primarily occupied by Trinidadian immigrants, challenged me to overcome my fear and preconceptions.

------

Just food for thought. I think your essay is already very good.

Ron

Get the most out of your LSAT Prep Plus subscription.

Analyze and track your performance with our Testing and Analytics Package.